Is it normal to lose eyelashes when removing mascara?

This post may contain affiliate links. At no cost to you we may earn a commission. See our full disclosure for more info.

Applying mascara can be fun and exciting, especially when it helps you achieve a specific makeup look. 

However, it can also be stressful, especially if you observe your lashes falling or thinning out whenever you use them. 

Of course, it’s normal to see eyelash fallouts from time to time. However, it shouldn’t always happen, especially if you’re only removing mascara.

I have compiled some expert advice to help you avoid this issue. 

Read on to find out more. 

Does Mascara Remove Eyelashes?

According to the CEO of Miami Skin Institute, S. Manjula Jegasothy, M.D., removing your mascara shouldn’t hurt or damage your lashes. 

But this doesn’t mean that it wouldn’t cause fallouts.

Mascara’s ingredients are generally safe, so using them should not lead to your eyelashes falling out.

However, the act of applying and removing mascara may pull out your lashes. 

Why Do I Lose Eyelashes When Removing Mascara?

If your eyelashes keep breaking or falling out when you remove your mascara, you need to start finding ways to stop it. 

But first, you need to find out why removing your mascara causes you to lose eyelashes. 

Here are some of the most common reasons why this happens:

You are not being gentle when removing mascara

You have to remind yourself that your eyelashes are delicate. 

They can easily break, so you need to be gentle with them. 

If you aggressively or forcefully remove mascara, you will definitely see a few lashes fall from your eyelids. 

You are forcefully removing mascara without a makeup remover

If you refuse to use the right products and tools for removing mascara, you will definitely damage your lashes.

Without the right products, you might be tempted to keep pulling and tugging your lashes to remove mascara. 

This will potentially lead to breakage and fallouts. 

You don’t remove mascara before you hit the bed

Another culprit why your lashes fall out when removing mascara is when you don’t remove them on time. 

This means that you probably sleep with your mascara on. 

When this happens, the product will stay on your lashes more than necessary. 

This makes it harder to remove mascara. 

Getting rid of the product will require more patience. 

If not, you will end up with heavily damaged lashes. 

You use an eyelash curler after applying mascara

In your attempt to achieve curly lashes, you might want to use mascara and an eyelash curler at the same time. 

However, if you apply mascara before using an eyelash curler, it would lead to lash damage. 

Your eyelashes may weaken, so when it’s time to remove your mascara, your lashes may fall out. 

How to Remove Mascara without Eyelashes Falling Out

If you want to avoid seeing your eyelashes fall out when removing mascara, you need to practice caution. 

This means that you need to be careful whenever you want to get rid of your mascara. 

The following tips can help ensure that you can safely remove mascara without damaging your eyelashes:

Avoid using too much waterproof mascara

Using waterproof mascara can help your lashes appear fuller and thicker. 

However, too much use of this product may lead to serious eyelash damage. 

Waterproof mascara is truly difficult to wash off. This sometimes leads to eyelash fallouts. 

You can still use waterproof mascara, but ensure you limit them to special occasions only. 

Don’t wear it every day to ensure your lashes don’t grow weak.

Use oil-based products to remove mascara

Choose your makeup removers wisely. 

Don’t settle for less and ensure you buy one that works really well. 

For best results, consider looking for oil-based makeup removers. 

They are usually effective when getting rid of stubborn makeup, including mascara.

Look for products such as ones with coconut oil, castor oil, or jojoba oil. 

These natural oils are effective in removing makeup without being harsh on your lashes.

Wet your lashes with water prior to using a makeup remover

Consider rinsing your makeup with water as a first makeup removing step. 

This helps dissolve your mascara, which makes it easier for you to remove the rest of it.

Do not rub your lashes when drying

After using makeup remover and washing your face, pat dry with a face towel or facial tissue. 

Never aggressively rub your towel against your eyelashes because this may pull your lashes unintentionally. 

Use a q-tip to get rid of mascara residue

After all your cleansing and makeup removing routine, check your eyelashes for residue. 

If you see excess product, use a q-tip to remove the remaining mascara.

Dab the q-tip in a lash moisturizer or serum and gently stroke your eyelashes. 

This helps get rid of remaining mascara while leaving products that improve the health of your lashes.

Which Mascara Comes Off the Easiest

If you want to avoid the issue of losing eyelashes whenever removing mascara, you can consider changing your makeup. 

Switching your mascara to an easy-to-remove one will be safer and gentler to your lashes. 

This means that if you use these types of mascara, you no longer have to worry too much about fallouts. 

The following are some of the most recommended products for mascara lovers: 

  • Bobbi Brown Intensifying Long-Wear Mascara
  • Elizabeth Arden Ceramide Lash Extending Treatment Mascara
  • Estée Lauder Double Wear Zero-Smudge Lengthening Mascara
  • LANCÔME GRANDIÔSE – Wide-Angle Fan Effect Mascara
  • BENEFIT COSMETICS Roller Lash Curling & Lifting Mascara 
  • ARMANI BEAUTY Eyes To Kill Waterproof Mascara
  • TARTE Tarteist™ Lash Paint Mascara
  • MILK MAKEUP Mini RISE Lifting + Lengthening Mascara
  • KAJA Wink Lash Trio Mascara
  • SEPHORA COLLECTION Big By Definition Defining & Volumizing Mascara

These are some of the most raved mascara that received excellent reviews from actual users. 

They are said to volumize and lengthen lashes. 

Some of these are even waterproof, but hundreds and thousands of users claim they can be easily removed.

You can try using a product or two on this list just to see which mascara is best for you.

How to Protect Eyelashes from Mascara

You can also reduce eyelash fallouts by protecting your lashes from mascara. 

This means that you can use products and follow techniques to achieve stronger, healthier eyelashes.

Here are some methods that you can follow: 

Ensure your eyelashes are always moisturized

If your lashes are always dry and stiff because of the constant use of mascara, it can slowly weaken your lashes. 

To avoid this issue, apply a lash serum or moisturizer regularly. 

Make sure to include it in your daily routine so your lashes will remain strong and healthy.

Find a safe and effective mascara primer 

Like using primer for your face, it’s best to apply a primer for your lashes as well. 

Before applying mascara, you need to prime your lashes first. 

Mascara primers usually have wax blends that help protect your lashes and ensure mascara is flawlessly applied to your lashes. 

Be cautious when choosing a mascara brand

Choose your mascara carefully. 

Ensure that the product also contains ingredients that improve the health of your lashes. 

Find brands of mascara that don’t contain synthetic dyes and formaldehyde. 

Take Biotin

Improve the health of your lashes by taking Biotin.

Biotin is not only good for your lashes. 

It also improves your skin and nails.


Again, it’s not normal to lose eyelashes whenever you remove mascara. 

However, eyelash fallouts are common, especially if you are not using a safe and proper way of removing mascara.

Hopefully, the details and tips mentioned in this post can help you avoid losing any more of your lashes. 

Ensure you follow appropriate techniques so you can continue wearing mascara without risking eyelash fallouts.