brown vs black mascara (Which one is the best for you)

This post may contain affiliate links. At no cost to you we may earn a commission. See our full disclosure for more info.

Finding out that mascara can easily make you look and feel great is definitely life-changing. 

It can bring joy and excitement, especially for those who are just starting to learn about makeup.

However, following the proper techniques in using and applying mascara may sometimes become overwhelming. 

This is especially true when it comes to choosing what color mascara to use. 

So the big question is, “Should you use brown or black mascara”?

The quick answer is it depends on your natural hair color. If your hair is naturally black, wearing black mascara is the ideal option. If not, swiping brown mascara on your lashes is the best choice. 

Also, according to makeup artists, you need to consider other factors such as eye color and skin tone when choosing between black and brown mascara.

Read on to discover more about this.

brown vs black mascara

Brown Mascara

Brown mascara is earning popularity among women. 

It’s softer and more subtle compared to black mascara. 

While it’s underrated compared to black mascara, wearing brown mascara can be a game-changer. 

If you have light hair color, using brown mascara may be suitable for you. 

You can also choose different shades of brown. 

This makes it easier for you to choose the most flattering brown mascara that you can wear.

Removing brown mascara is not as difficult as black mascara. 

It’s not intensely pigmented, so removing it will not be a hassle. 

The minor problem with brown mascara is that it won’t help you achieve bold looks. 

So, if you are more into dramatic eye makeup looks, brown mascara may not be an ideal option for you.

black mascara

Black mascara is probably the default color of mascara that most women use. 

It’s a go-to product that helps effectively complete your dramatic or no-makeup look. 

It can help volumize, lengthen, and darken your lashes. 

This helps enhance your eyes and may even give the illusion that they are wider or bigger. 

Black mascara, however, can easily smudge, making it difficult to remove. 

This is especially true if you use black waterproof mascara.

It’s super pigmented, so it may leave a stain or spot on your skin when you make a mistake during application. 

When this happens, your eye makeup may be ruined. 

Thus, caution and precision are important when applying black mascara.

is brown or black mascara better

There is no definite answer if you are wondering whether brown or black mascara is better. 

In the end, it boils down to your preferences. 

For instance, if you are more into no makeup and soft makeup looks, going for brown mascara may be the better option. 

If you love attention-grabbing makeup, using black mascara will be perfect for you. 

This only shows that there is no right or wrong answer when it comes to choosing your mascara color.

However, you might still want to find out some useful tips about these mascara colors. 

I personally recommend learning which particular mascara complements your eye color and skin tone. 

should you wear brown or black mascara

Your eye color may also be a factor to consider in choosing whether you should wear brown or black mascara. 

Take note that you can wear either black or brown mascara regardless of your eye color. 

It’s just that there are specific options recommended by makeup users.

To help you decide, I have gathered some insights about wearing black or brown mascara depending on eye colors.

brown vs black mascara for green eyes

If you want to bring out your green eyes, using brown mascara will work for you. 

Brown mascara can highlight the color of your irises, helping you rock a natural, subtle, but gorgeous eye makeup. 

brown or black mascara for blue eyes

Brown mascara is also more suitable for women with blue eyes. 

Wearing black mascara may lead to a makeup look that appears too bold or dark. 

So if you decide to wear it instead of brown mascara, your blue eyes may not look as prominent as you want them to be.

Wearing brown mascara, on the other hand, highlights your blue eyes. 

It also looks natural, so you can totally rock a no-makeup look.

brown or black mascara for hazel eyes

The best way to highlight the gold specks in your irises is to wear brown mascara. 

The warm tones of brown mascara can effectively make your hazel eyes look like “the bomb”.

You can still try wearing black mascara if you have hazel eyes. 

Doing so can help you achieve a natural look as well.

brown vs black mascara for brown eyes

Black mascara is highly recommended for women with brown eyes. 

It helps lift the color of your irises without making them look too light or too dark. 

Contrasting your brown eyes with black mascara also helps complete your natural makeup look. 

Wearing brown mascara if you have brown eyes can work as well. 

It accents your eyes’ chocolate shade. 

This works if you want your eye color to be more noticeable.

brown vs black mascara for your skin tone

If you are fair-skinned, using brown mascara looks more natural. 

It helps make you look like you are not wearing makeup, even if you apply a brown volumizing mascara. 

Women who have really dark skin, however, may look best if they wear black mascara instead of brown mascara. 

If you have dark skin, brown mascara will only blend with your skin tone. 

This means that wearing brown mascara will create a monotone look.

This may not be a great idea if you want your eye makeup to stand out. 

Additional Tips when Choosing between Black and Brown Mascara

Aside from the color of your eyes and your skin tone, you can also consider the type of makeup look you are going after. 

For example, if you are aiming to create smokey eye makeup, using black mascara is the best option. 

Wearing brown mascara while wearing bold eyeshadows will make your makeup look awkward. So, choosing black mascara works best. 

However, if you use natural and subtle eyeshadows, brown mascara will work for you. 

You might also want to consider the color of your eyeliner. 

If you are wearing black eyeliner, better pair it with black mascara. 

If you are wearing brown eyeliner, complement it with brown mascara. 


You can either choose black or brown mascara. 

Both will help you enhance your lashes and improve your appearance. 

Black mascara may look best if you are a fan of bold and dark looks. 

Brown mascara is suitable if you want a subtle and more natural look.

However, you still need to consider your eye color, skin tone, and eye makeup when choosing between these two.

Anyway, regardless of the tips mentioned here, it’s still your choice whether you choose to wear black or brown mascara. 

It all boils down to your preference, especially when it’s about complementing the rest of your makeup look.

Hopefully, you have gathered enough tips on how to choose between brown and black mascara. 

You can also read other makeup tips in our blog like this post: “Is It Bad To Sleep With Mascara On?” or “Can You Put Mascara On Lash Extensions?”.